top of page

New Plymouth backs voting rights for non-elected committee members

Writer: Craig Ashworth
Craig Ashworth
3 minutes ago
3 min read

New Plymouth has joined the call for the Government to allow non-elected committee members to keep their voting rights.


At a meeting on Wednesday evening, New Plymouth District Council (NPDC) voted 12-3 to send a letter asking for an exemption to the new law restricting committee voting rights to elected councillors, in step with other district councils including Far North, Hastings and Porirua.


In September, local government minister Simon Watts announced the law change would “strengthen local democracy and accountability” when it took effect next March.


Watts said councils could apply for exceptions, but he expected to grant them rarely.


New Plymouth council’s iwi liaison committee Te Huinga Taumatua has five members appointed by the district’s iwi agencies, sitting with five councillors.


The Finance, Audit and Risk Committee has two appointed members, including the chair, sitting alongside the mayor and six councillors.


Elected councillors have the final say on almost all committee recommendations.


Mayor Max Brough and co-deputy mayor Murray Chong, who have strong New Zealand First links, voted against an exemption, as did ACT Party councillor Damon Fox.


Mayor Max Brough and his co-deputy Murray Chong don't want appointed committee members to vote.
Mayor Max Brough and his co-deputy Murray Chong don't want appointed committee members to vote.

Brough said councillors were elected to make tough decisions and be accountable for them.


“I remain committed to democracy.


“Therefore I cannot in good conscience, on my values, support non-elected members having voting rights.”


Fox said unelected members voting on committees struck at the very foundation of democracy.


“Nobody is being excluded from contributing to the conversation.


“Their contributions can still inform, challenge, and improve decisions we make, and so they should.


“However, there is a fundamental difference between having a voice and having a vote.”


Councillor Dinnie Moeahu says asking for an exception to the voting ban is part of democracy.
Councillor Dinnie Moeahu says asking for an exception to the voting ban is part of democracy.

Councillor Dinnie Moeahu said the chance to retain voting rights was part of democracy.


“It has come to us as a legal pathway set by the Government. That's democracy.


“We now have the opportunity for us to say to that Government ‘can we have an exemption please?’”


Councillor Sam Bennett also wanted the letter sent.


“I don't think democracy has been lost.


“It's been enhanced by having people around the table that can influence elected members to vote in really important decisions, by the community that put us all here.”


Councillor John Woodward said the expertise of appointed committee members improved governance, fiscal responsibility and risk mitigation.


“Why would we not bring the subject matter experts around the table?


“Having five of our own local iwi representatives on that committee feeding directly into council is absolutely critical.”


The council’s letter to Watts says Te Huinga Taumatua iwi representatives would be demoted from decision-makers to advisers, within a committee designed as a partnership.


“Iwi representatives would lose their direct influence … and the trust and confidence the partnership has been built on would be at risk.


“No procedural alternative can replace what voting membership … provides, which is shared responsibility for, and ownership of, the Committee's decisions.”


The letter says if no exceptions are granted NPDC could appoint more councillors to the Finance, Audit and Risk Committee, or seek specialist advice.


“Neither would replicate the technical expertise, structural independence and collective responsibility provided by specialist external members participating fully in Committee deliberations, and neither provides an equivalent form of independent governance assurance.”


Watts will decide whether to recommend any exceptions to the no-voting rule, which would then be formally granted by the Governor General.


nā Craig Ashworth craig@tekorimako.co.nz


LDR is local body journalism hosted by Te Korimako o Taranaki and funded by Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa and Irirangi te Motu.



Comments


bottom of page